I absolutely adored this episode when I first watched it, and fell totally in love with Moonlight after watching it. ( I had thought I loved Moonlight before, but this was a whole other level.) I'm not sure if I even noticed the oddness of the ice cubes the first time I watched it, I was so caught up in the story! Though I watched it so many times during that first year, it's a little hard to remember exactly what I noticed, or missed, the very first time. I do remember feeling as if the show had really come together during this episode, that the show truly now knew what it was and where it was going. (I still feel that way after re-watching, too, even though I now know how crazy things still were behind the scenes.)
On re-watch, I still adored this episode. One of the first things I noticed was how comfortable Mick and Beth were with each other, compared to how they had been in the previous episodes. There were plenty of awkward moments for them to get through, but there was a connection between them here I just hadn't felt before. It also felt to me that this was the first really strong story in the series. (I did find myself wondering why I felt that way about the story, since there weren't really fewer plot holes than there were in the other episodes. I suppose it's because I found the story to be so emotionally satisfying.) I really loved the production, as well. So many things came together in this episode, like the music .... they had used good songs at the end before, but previously I'd found the incidental music to be kind of jarring. In Fever, there was such good use of multiple songs, "Vanished", "Just Like Everyone" and "Into Dust" all used at the absolute perfect moments. And for the first time I really liked the incidental music as well, especially the music used during the bathtub scene... it was just exquisite.
This was a great episode for Josh, too. We already knew he was a good guy, but this episode really made it clear how devoted he was to his job and how courageous he was. I really enjoyed the scenes where Mick and Josh were together ... talk about awkward! Mick's jealousy was quite obvious, but he did manage to stay civil. The scene where Mick went through the safe house was very striking. We'd seen Mick "smell the past" before, but there was something especially vivid about the way he did it here. It seemed more that he was
experiencing what had happened than that he was just seeing it. It was so chilling seeing how the police were gathering evidence and trying to figure what happened .... while Mick
knew exactly what had happened and had, in a way, lived through it. Mick also was very blunt about presenting what had actually happened, either because he was trying to show off for Josh out of jealousy, or maybe because of the intensity of the past he'd just experienced. It was probably foolish of him to mention detecting estrogen in the blood, but I don't really see where that would be dangerous. Josh would figure he's either got an amazing sense of smell, or that he's a charlatan (I had the impression Josh felt as if he'd hired a psychic) ... it doesn't seem likely anyone would leap to a vampire conclusion. (And we already know that Mick isn't exactly "extremely careful' about concealing his secret, either.) I think jumping down the fire escape was a lot more foolish, and was certainly dangerous, but still, it totally seems like something Mick would do.

(And maybe, with his vampire senses, he actually knew that no one would see him do it? Hmm.) And wow, I sure did love it when he did that! Vampire jumping scenes are awesome.
One thing about Josh's actions that I didn't think about until this viewing was the way he slugged his assistant when he found out he was the leak. It was a very satisfying moment, but it occurred to me this time that Josh probably really damaged his case against the guy by doing that. But overall, what a great episode for Josh this was.
Leni was also a wonderful character, and I thought the actress did a brilliant job playing her. I loved Mick's interactions with Leni, and had to smile when Mick said that sort of thing was not his forte. He was so compassionate toward her, and he really did understand her so well. (In fact his interaction with her kind of convinced me that he'd grown up with a much younger sister.) The moment when he realized Leni was pregnant was just so lovely.... and he even did a pretty good job explaining, with logic, how he'd known that! And oh, that moment in the restroom when Leni asked if Mick had kids. The expression on Mick's face was just heartbreaking.
I particularly loved the little moments that reminded me of Mick's actual age, like the way he tipped his hat to the woman and little girl leaving the restroom. (And how wonderful it was to contrast that bit of ritual politeness with the fact that he was barging into the womens' restroom.) It was quite an awkward moment, but I wasn't surprised that the woman didn't report him; it actually didn't even occur to me that she might. (Maybe that's because I was so charmed by the hat-tipping; now that MLC mentioned it, it sure does seem like that would be a risk.) And how much I loved Mick's voice-over about his experience in the Battle of the Bulge! Considering Mick's age, knowing that he was a young man during World War II, there was just no way he wouldn't have been caught up in it, and I was SO hoping that the show would acknowledge that. I can't really describe how happy I was when it did! And that was another amazing contrast, Mick's description of the freezing cold and frostbite he'd experienced back then versus the terrible heat that was killing him now.
And there were such great vampire moments too, like the voice-over when Mick admitted that if things got too bad, he wouldn't be able to stop himself from feeding on Leni. That's so horrific to think about, that no matter how totally he was committed to protecting her, no amount of will power could stop that from happening. It really brought home why Mick hates his vampire state so much, since we'd seen so much of how useful being a vampire could be. (I did find myself wondering if Mick was right about that, or if maybe he had more self control than he knew, but it seems like he was probably correct about that.)
The bathtub scene was amazing, and the ending scene was, somehow, even better. Now that I've watched Fever's ending again, I think I can safely say that it is my absolute favorite Moonlight ending. "Into Dust" is utterly perfect in the scene, and Mick and Beth leaning on each side of the door, so very close to each other and yet so far apart, was possibly the most beautiful scene in the show. I love that they didn't see or speak to each other, and we only heard Mick's voice-over.
And, going on to the little issues the episode had, I was once again too caught up in the story to really notice them (though I
did notice all the signs that the motel was undergoing renovation, at last!) The ice cubes somehow never bothered me all that much, except for the weird way they never, ever melted. (It must have taken Beth over an hour to get there, Mick was burning up with fever, and the ice cubes didn't melt?) Of course, perhaps Leni kept on bringing in more buckets of ice, and we just didn't see that. The other thing that I thought was odd in my early viewings was the way Beth answered her phone when Leni called ... it seemed very odd that she said "Beth Turner." When I watched this years ago, I'd never had a smart phone, so it didn't occur to me to wonder why Beth didn't notice this was Mick's phone calling her. I wondered about that, this time, but then it occurred to me that maybe Leni wasn't using Mick's phone. I don't remember her ever giving back the cop's phone, so maybe that was the one she was using, and Beth might not so readily have remembered that name. (However, I did often wonder why the motel didn't have a land line.)
It did occur to me at some point to wonder why Beth hadn't prepared, and brought blood bags with her, or why Mick hadn't had Leni call Josef instead, but on reflection I think what happened in the episode actually made more sense. Mick was obsessed then with protecting Leni, and I can't imagine him letting Josef get near her at that time. (And he was in such bad shape he definitely wasn't thinking clearly .... it seemed like he just wanted to see Beth once more before he died.) And even if he had been thinking clearly, how would Mick have relayed through Leni how Beth should go about procuring blood bags? Beth wouldn't have known where to get them, and she certainly had no problem with the idea of giving her own blood to Mick. I wondered, this time, if she'd been planning to give her own blood to Mick ever since she got the call.....
Scorecard so far:
Mick saves Beth--- II
Beth saves Mick--- lll